NewsWorldControversy around a new family of "potentially habitable" exoplanets

Controversy around a new family of “potentially habitable” exoplanets


Published on :

Cambridge scientists invented, Tuesday, August 24, a new family of exoplanets – called “hycean” – which could multiply the chances of finding other habitable planets in the universe. A theory that does not satisfy everyone in the scientific world.

This sounds like good news for anyone hoping to spot alien life forms. They could exist on a much larger number of planets than on those which held the attention of the researchers until now, ie the planets “twin” of the Earth.

A Cambridge University research team defined a new category of worlds that could be habitable, dubbed “Hycean” planets, in an article accepted August 26 by the Astrophysical Journal.

Already eleven “candidate” planets

These have nothing to do with Earth. These exoplanets – i.e. outside our solar system – are more like super-Earths or mini-Neptunes, i.e. they can be more than twice the size of Earth , but less than four times, as is the case with Neptune.

In addition, a “Hycean” planet would be covered with water, endowed with an atmosphere full of hydrogen and the temperature on its surface “would be within the limit of what is considered acceptable on Earth for life forms”, summarizes Nikku Madhusudhan, astrophysicist at the University of Cambridge and main author of the article on these planets, interviewed by France 24.

“We have found eleven candidate planets ‘Hycean’ which are several tens of light years from here and which seem to us to be very suitable worlds for looking for biological signatures,” he adds.

For the authors of this study, the existence of potentially habitable “Hycean” worlds considerably widens the field of possibilities in the discovery of traces of extraterrestrial life. There are, in fact, far fewer Earth-sized planets in the universe than larger stars like these mini-Neptunes.

Additionally, smaller planets – like ours – have much weaker atmospheric signatures than larger ones, which “makes it easier to detect life forms on ‘Hycean’ type worlds,” says Nikku Madhusudhan.

“If these planets are inhabited, we will be able to have the first records of biological signatures in just two or three years”, ignites the Cambridge astrophysicist. This will be thanks to the James Webb space telescope, which is due to be commissioned this year “and will be able to easily probe the atmosphere of these eleven candidate planets”, concludes Nikku Madhusudhan.

K2-18b, exoplanet of discord

But let the alien hunters moderate their hopes. The conclusions of the Cambridge researchers are far from unanimous. “We do not know if planets such as described in this article really exist. For the moment, it is purely theoretical”, affirms Martin Turbet, astrophysicist at the astronomical observatory of Geneva, contacted by France 24.

All the scientific imbroglio goes back to the starting point of the hypothesis of habitable “Hycean” planets. It is an exoplanet called K2-18b, located about 124 light years from Earth. Nikku Madhusudhan’s team believes, in a previous article published a year and a half ago, that this mini-Neptune may well have all the conditions required: large amounts of water, an atmosphere rich in hydrogen and an acceptable temperature for life on its surface.

K2-18b then becomes the mother of the family of “Hycean” planets. “From our research on K2-18b, we established a model that allowed us to calculate the conditions necessary for planets with a hydrogen-rich atmosphere to be habitable,” explains the Cambridge scientist.

Except that Nikku Madhusudhan is a bit alone in finding that K2-18b could be habitable. “We never succeeded in reproducing the calculations which allowed him to reach his conclusion”, affirms Jérémy Leconte, astrophysicist at the University of Bordeaux, contacted by France 24. The other scientists questioned by France 24 also confirmed have doubts about the model used by the Cambridge researcher.

Either way, there would be “something physically wrong with the idea of ​​a planet at the right surface temperature, covered in water and with an atmosphere so rich in hydrogen”, adds Olivier Mousis, astrophysicist at Aix-Marseille University.

He explains that in this type of world, there would be a lot of water that would evaporate in the atmosphere, thus generating a strong greenhouse effect that would greatly heat the surface of the planet. “The temperature of the ocean would rise until the water becomes hypercorrosive, which is not a welcoming environment for life”, summarizes Olivier Mousis.

So many criticisms that Nikku Madhusudhan rejects. “I have nothing against scientists having other opinions, this is part of the necessary debate of ideas, but so far there have been no publications that have refuted our conclusions. in the end, that’s what counts, isn’t it? “says the Cambridge astrophysicist.

In the end, the James Webb Space Telescope may be the arbiter of this scientific quarrel, if it manages to detect traces of life on one of these planets. And what would these life forms look like? This is a point on which Nikku Madhusudhan and the other researchers interviewed by France 24 at least agree: we have no idea and anything is possible.


  1. Download Hypnotic Brass Ensemble – BAD BOYS OF JAZZ Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Brian Hyland – Warmed over Kisses Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Carl Smith And The Natural Gas Company – Burnin’ Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Pretty Lightning – Jangle Bowls Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Rebecca Zamolo – Rewind the Musical Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Stephen Chikazaza – Familiar People Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Rulo y la Contrabanda – Basado en hechos reales (Deluxe Edition) Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Grave Dust – The Pale Hand – EP Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Zap Kids – Kids United – EP Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Carmina Huatuco – Linda Candelita Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Qveen Herby – Ep 5 – EP Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Zuin – Per tutti questi anni Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Lunar Spirit – Ashes & Gold Album Mp3 Zip
    Download YB Cortes – Before It All – EP Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Baring Teeth – Transitive Savagery Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Candy66 – Siempre Fuertes (Archivo) (Vol.1) Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Shacara Rogers – 16 Moments Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Mickey Galyean & Cullen’s Bridge – Songs From the Blue Ridge Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Xenobiotic – Prometheus Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Tino Rossi – Les plus beaux airs d’opérette / Opérettes et comédies musicales (Remasterisé en 2018) Album Mp3 Zip
    Download LIV’n’G – Shades – EP Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Danny Boudreau – Je suis à l’âme – EP Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Flynn Gurry – Flynn Gurry – EP Album Mp3 Zip
    Download The Monster Inside – The War Within Us – EP Album Mp3 Zip
    Download Resinated – The Morning After, Pt. 3 – EP Album Mp3 Zip

Comments are closed.

Latest news

Roland-Garros: Diane Parry out in the 3rd round – archyde

The dream has evaporated. Soared like his wooded backhand in the Parisian sky on the 4th match point....

Roland-Garros – Playing a Frenchman in Paris, a certain idea of ​​hell? – Eurosport EN

This is perhaps the big deal at the start of this fortnight. The public of Roland-Garros, more actor...

This is Luis Diaz in data: age, goals and assists with Liverpool, career

Between a dirt court and a coal mine, this is how Luis Díaz was forged 3:08 (CNN Spanish) --...

Salmonella in Kinder: “too late” apologies for Romy’s father, the little Varoise hospitalized in March

At the other end of the line, Romy's laughter sometimes hides...

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you