Alcohol, deception and homosexuality: Netflix’s first pan-Arab film is controversial

Published on : 01/26/2022 – 12:26Modified : 01/26/2022 – 12:29

Netflix wanted to strike a blow with its first pan-Arab production “Ashab wala Aaz” (“The best friends in the world” in Arabic). The objective has been achieved: in Egypt, the most populous of the Arab countries, some are agitated to banish him and the others rush to see him.

It was the expected sensation of the beginning of the year: the film brings together well-known actors from Lebanon and Egypt, the two behemoths of Arab pop culture. And it is the remake of a successful Italian feature film, “Perfect Strangers” – whose French version, “Le jeu”, has already been a hit on the online platform.

Three days after its release, “Ashab wala Aaz”, which tells of a game between friends that goes wrong, is at the top of the ten most-watched films on Netflix in the Arab world.

But in Egypt, a lawyer seized the Ministry of Culture and the censorship service to “ban” a film which, he says, “aims to break family values” and MP Moustafa Bakri called for an extraordinary session of Parliament to look into the matter.

Ban Netflix

The story is that of three couples – two Lebanese, an Egyptian – who meet for a boozy dinner. During the evening, they agree to play a game: put their laptop on the table and share each message or call with the whole group. Wives discover mistresses, friends of betrayals, husbands of liaisons and the group that one of them is homosexual, in an almost closed door.

Moustafa Bakri, he claims to have scrutinized each plan. Results ? “There are more than twenty pornographic scenes”, he asserts – while no erotic scene, not even a kiss, appears in the film, which Netflix prohibits for children under 16 for its coarse language.

The deputy, who regularly sets himself up as a guardian of morals, has gone on all the sets of the most watched talk shows in the country to demand nothing less than the outright banning of Netflix in Egypt.

The fault of “Ashab wala Aaz”? Show a father discussing with his daughter about her first sexual relationship after her mother discovered condoms in her bag and “defend homosexuality when we are an oriental society”, accuses Moustafa Bakri.

“There is a difference between not denouncing a phenomenon and encouraging it”, replies film critic Tarek al-Chennaoui in a country where homosexuality is not expressly prohibited but where the repression of LGBTQ+ people has increased since the election of President Abdel Fattah al-Sissi in 2014.

An actress criticized

And above all, argues Tarek al-Chennaoui, Egyptian cinema has never been cautious.

Almost 20 years ago, the public rushed into theaters for “Sahr el-Layali” (“White Nights” in Arabic), the story of four couples who tear themselves apart after a dinner with friends with, on the menu, male impotence, adultery and differences between social classes.

Several Egyptian films, including “The Yacoubian Building”, adapted from the novel by Alaa Al-Aswani, have already dealt with homosexuality explicitly.

And the height of irony, in 2016, the prize for best screenplay at the Cairo Film Festival was awarded to… “Perfect Strangers”!

But in a country where conservatism and a rigorous reading of Islam have continued to progress, one woman concentrates all the criticism: the only Egyptian actress in the film, Mona Zaki.

On screen, she plays a woman caught between a stepmother who despises her and a husband who no longer touches her. In the city, Internet users reduce the actress – who was playing in “Sahr al-Layali” alongside her husband Ahmed Helmi at their debut – to her sole status as a wife.

Rather than addressing her, they call out to her husband, Ahmed Helmi, one of the most famous Egyptian actors who is not in the Netflix cast.

“How could he allow his wife to play this role?”, Writes one. Others go even further and ask him to repudiate her immediately.

“It’s a courageous and original film”, retorts on Facebook Khaled Ali, a great figure of the Egyptian left. “Everything he talks about does exist in our societies, no offense to those who prefer to ignore it, keep silent or attack”.

With AFP