• Wed. Jan 19th, 2022

“Global” corporate tax: why Amazon could get away with it

Byeditorial

Jun 7, 2021

Published on :

The G7 Finances proposed, on Saturday, better taxation of multinationals by suggesting the creation of a global floor rate of 15% for corporate tax. But a provision targeting the profits of the Internet giants seems to exclude Amazon, yet one of the champions of tax optimization.

This is the figure that everyone has been putting forward since the agreement described as historic for a new global corporate tax, found on Saturday, June 5, by the G7 countries. The minimum tax rate of 15% should make it possible to “put an end to the race for the lowest tax rate for companies,” said Janet Yellen, the US Secretary of the Treasury, in particular.

While this rate has been hailed as a tremendous leap forward in the fight against tax havens by a large number of commentators, several specialists in the fight against tax fraud yet qualified it insufficient. It is, in fact, barely higher than the corporate tax applied in Ireland (13%), a country notoriously accommodating for the tech giants from a tax standpoint, and much lower than the rate of 21% proposed by the president. American Joe Biden, at the origin of the movement for a global taxation of multinationals.

>> To read: The United States relaunches the global battle against tax optimization

Amazon saved by its low profit margin ?

“We could have expected a floor of around 20%, which would have been close to the average tax rate for OECD countries”, summarizes Richard Murphy, associate professor of accounting at the school of management of the University of Sheffield and specialist in international taxation, contacted by France 24.

But this rate of 15% is not the only disappointment of some experts since the announcement of the G7 Finances. Another figure, much less publicized, has just as attracted the attention of NGOs like Taxe Justice Network or the Fair Tax Foundation, because it seems to offer an escape route to one of the champions of tax optimization: Amazon.

In their final communiqué, the members of the G7 finance add a rule that should only apply to large groups whose profit margin exceeds 10%. Part of the profits of these multinationals may be taxed in the countries where they carry out a real activity, even if they do not have a “physical” presence there in the form of a head office, for example.

This measure of “fairer distribution of tax revenues” appears “tailor-made to allow better taxation of tech giants like Apple, Google or Facebook, which achieve a profit margin easily exceeding 20%,” said Richard Murphy. It seems to cover the case of these very profitable multinationals which have established, for example, their European headquarters in Luxembourg to repatriate the major part of their turnover there and benefit from the very advantageous tax rate of the Grand Duchy.

>> Tax optimization: why is Luxembourg so attractive ?

It is in this way that the European subsidiary of Amazon was able to escape tax in Luxembourg on the 44 billion euros of income derived from its sales throughout the Old Continent in 2020. An assembly pointed out like this ” one of the most glaring examples of what had to be taken into account in the fight against tax optimization, recalls the British daily The Guardian.

Except that, thanks to the 10% profit margin rule, Amazon would go through an entire section of the new global taxation rules proposed by the G7 Finances. The e-commerce giant indeed has a peculiarity compared to other behemoths of the Net: “Its aggressive pricing policy to gain market share and its economic model closer to mass distribution than to the digital economy means that Amazon has a lower profit margin, ”recalls Markus Meinzer, analyst for the NGO Tax Justice Network, contacted by France 24. A margin that stands at around 6%.

Separate Amazon’s activities to better tax them

In other words, Amazon would, of course, be subject to the new “global” corporate tax of at least 15%, like all other large multinationals, but the rule specifically designed for the Internet giants most fond of tax optimization could not be applied to it. “It would be a shame when Amazon was still one of the main targets of this effort to fight against these practices”, regrets Richard Murphy.

Mass has not yet been said, however. The G7 Finance proposal will still be the subject of many negotiations and “it is possible to improve what is on the table”, assures Richard Murphy. One of the most obvious solutions would be to tax separate the two main core businesses of Amazon. The group is not only a large Internet supermarket, it also has “a web services activity (like its hosting offers in the“ cloud ”, Editor’s note) very profitable and growing, whose profit margin is largely greater than 20% ”, points out Markus Meinzer. By targeting this specific activity, the new international taxation rules on the distribution of tax revenues could affect a significant portion of Amazon’s profits.

For Tax Justice Network, it is all the more important not to let the group take advantage of this loophole because otherwise “other giants of the Net could try to do the same”, underlines Alex Cobham, director of the NGO, questioned by The Guardian.

But Markus Meinzer is not the most optimistic. “The G7 Finance proposal is already less ambitious than the initial idea of ​​US President Joe Biden, who had campaigned for a 21% corporate tax rate, and the fact that this clause exists with regard to the profit margin shows that we will have to pay attention to every detail. The lobbies of the large groups will seek to add more and more exceptions to their advantage, ”he concludes. The analyst fears that at each step of the process – validation of the rules by the G20 this summer, then negotiations between the OECD countries – new sticks will be put in the wheels of greater tax justice.

One thought on ““Global” corporate tax: why Amazon could get away with it”
  1. editorial says:

    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-pureskate-2-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110818471678248
    https://peatix.com/user/8540597
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-words-search-free-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110893487641102
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-abc-preschool-practice-handwriting-alphabet-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110763799615700
    https://peatix.com/user/8559141
    https://peatix.com/user/8535550
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-farmersio-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96045379718456
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-hacking-game-hack-bot-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96044293633572
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-word-connect-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96075196543860
    https://peatix.com/user/8556633
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-dont-look-back-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110881322747346
    https://peatix.com/user/8560175
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110874127445782
    https://peatix.com/user/8542159
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-car-parking-3d-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110834127697843
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-dangerous-car-driving-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110837874620075
    https://peatix.com/user/8540360
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-gym-gram-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110736174086286
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-stickman-ghost-ninja-warrior-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110781303256679
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-dice-roller-for-dd-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110914275378702
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99028050910513
    https://peatix.com/user/8534696
    https://peatix.com/user/8560516
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-lds-scripture-balloon-pop-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109280461533795
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-juegos-de-logica-2-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110741714486953
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-auto-parken-spiele-3d-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109281211900684
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-wiz-khalifas-weed-farm-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96044899609569
    https://peatix.com/user/8557395
    https://peatix.com/user/8561211
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-word-owls-kindergarten-search-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110765711708582
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-traffic-racing-behind-the-wheel-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110917988581741
    https://peatix.com/user/8552603
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-vip-games-klaverjassen-online-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109282792720520
    https://peatix.com/user/8558350
    https://peatix.com/user/8554006
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-cricket-practice-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110854544644661
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-helt-vildt-smadre-hit-3d-2020-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110748579572203
    https://peatix.com/user/8534987
    https://peatix.com/user/8542530
    https://peatix.com/user/8545515
    https://peatix.com/user/8561066
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-avakin-life-3d-virtual-world-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96041132068086
    https://peatix.com/user/8556422
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-punch-ball-3d-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110871668172052
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-24-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99014024150971
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-gorilla-robot-transformation-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110892258016419
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-the-simstm-freeplay-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110912281419797
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-motocross-stunt-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109311245688869
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110827774966224
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-big-win-baseball-2018-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110865682233503
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-die-pony-fabrik-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109247463822005
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-guitar-scorist-free-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110744867105402
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-online-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109257910585073
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110751284640883
    https://peatix.com/user/8528616
    https://peatix.com/user/8545939
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-play-game-tic-tac-toe-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110880807107894
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-ski-lodge-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109275937260243
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-rouge-noire-royal-solitaire-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109256189665761
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-trivia-sort-3d-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110813011993753
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-tap-to-cook-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110755765949401
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-line-rider-3d-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110907090527161
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-wall-dodge-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110748320369086
    https://peatix.com/user/8549605
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-tn-m-nhan-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110783627302919
    https://peatix.com/user/8550732
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-onet-classic-fruit-link-puzzle-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110913443722581
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-fingerboard-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110882403533599
    https://peatix.com/user/8561109
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-star-warstm-commander-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96073888853092
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-cosmo-race-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96080427799598
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-c-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110920807099357
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110887137869848
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-amazing-poke-monster-quiz-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99036052580855
    https://peatix.com/user/8560513
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-flute-master-aprende-flauta-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96073983076488
    https://peatix.com/user/8548481
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-sniper-animal-hunter-2017-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109257551459018
    https://peatix.com/user/8559675
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-billiards-pool-night-club-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109246952457776
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-brain-test-sharpen-your-memory-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99036350578306
    https://peatix.com/user/8559953
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-rolling-sky-ball-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99002736703345
    https://peatix.com/user/8559851
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-can-you-escape-haunted-house-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110802374229879
    https://peatix.com/user/8528884
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-heroes-empire-tcg-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110912545533020
    https://peatix.com/user/8560952
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-guess-car-quiz-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110914216553976
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-tute-by-conectagames-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110726549891325
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-soccer-real-stars-17-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110905249170933
    https://peatix.com/user/8549970
    https://peatix.com/user/8558460
    https://peatix.com/user/8560997
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-fu-master-stunt-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110755754816471
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-globesweeper-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110806306564914
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-deal-of-the-dead-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110866520643905
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-astraware-casino-hd-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110808510149892
    https://peatix.com/user/8557817
    https://peatix.com/user/8541572
    https://peatix.com/user/8559377
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-bleach-edition-quiz-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109269537309279
    https://peatix.com/user/8560964
    https://peatix.com/user/8530033
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-annelids-online-bitva-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96085563585880
    https://peatix.com/user/8560723
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-guess-the-word-puzzle-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99026224216715
    https://peatix.com/user/8542400
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-audrey-grants-better-bridge-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110760058541795
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-army-truck-driving-simulator-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110891368208349
    https://peatix.com/user/8550349
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-superheroe-para-colorear-libro-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110921896706303
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-ar-rps-cryptolord-worldopo-icq-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110885395036595
    https://peatix.com/user/8538311
    https://peatix.com/user/8560700
    https://peatix.com/user/8553855
    https://peatix.com/user/8532297
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-sallys-law-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109248593622978
    https://peatix.com/user/8559839
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-cribbage-game-board-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96308858413121
    https://peatix.com/user/8543165
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110751697206482
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-baby-heroes-save-the-city-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99005257789284
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-idle-restaurant-master-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110905226191340
    https://peatix.com/user/8560507
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-to-be-or-not-to-be-ryan-north-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96304089097897
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-sand-bagger-truck-simulator-echte-3d-bau-kran-spiel-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110857866099739
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110834598215688
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-roller-coaster-sunset-vr-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99029893181426
    https://peatix.com/user/8560594
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110730539864503
    https://peatix.com/user/8538136
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-color-hole-3d-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109258538346307
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-cocos-adventure-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96076916087693
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-sim-racing-telemetry-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96075694237873
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-circle-master-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109248065818429
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-juegos-educativos-puzzles-para-ninos-pequenos-2-de-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99010092925360
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-real-treasure-hunt-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110890053756633
    https://peatix.com/user/8538071
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-combatiente-rey-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96308662663167
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-hexpair-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99019370355664
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-beard-salon-beauty-makeover-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110837391782466
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-powerhouse-schaltung-gerangel-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110824995233495
    https://peatix.com/user/8554516
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96303906680452
    https://peatix.com/user/8560279
    https://peatix.com/user/8559633
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-pics2word-fun-word-guess-quiz-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110800650809855
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-idle-transformation-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96042665286980
    https://peatix.com/user/8552896
    https://peatix.com/user/8534375
    https://peatix.com/user/8543820
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-7-wonders-score-table-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110863544262505
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-trancaon-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110883660888085
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-huuuge-little-tanks-merger-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109302952582862
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-destiny-heroine-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96080722761969
    https://peatix.com/user/8529235
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-tricky-challenge-3-new-chapter-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96045920622284
    https://peatix.com/user/8552612
    https://peatix.com/user/8528909
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-whats-the-difference-spot-it-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110725548512224
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-rising-5-runy-asteros-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110747507833126
    https://peatix.com/user/8557063
    https://peatix.com/user/8540653
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-fishing-strike-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96045719538232
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-solitaire-for-christmas-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110886547225410
    https://peatix.com/user/8548330
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-zumu-trip-epic-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110905761697394
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-super-mega-runners-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96079479656907
    https://peatix.com/user/8560407
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-blast-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109247245836927
    https://peatix.com/user/8545777
    https://peatix.com/user/8529005
    https://peatix.com/user/8555571
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-prom-queen-high-school-love-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99010847208188
    https://peatix.com/user/8535007
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99009951222150
    https://peatix.com/user/8544920
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-furious-bike-escape-stunts-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110780509533654
    https://peatix.com/user/8549984
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/hack-guns-of-war-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109274433980798
    https://peatix.com/user/8557379
    https://peatix.com/user/8548012
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-rookstar-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110900849549678
    https://peatix.com/user/8531610
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-mindkeeper-the-lurking-fear-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96076864978788
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-broken-sword-1-directors-cut-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110885504696793
    https://peatix.com/user/8534384
    https://peatix.com/user/8559844
    https://peatix.com/user/8530376
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-baccarat-online-baccarist-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96083251796844
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-la-verdad-de-la-cripta-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-109307572729815
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/update-bigfoot-hunting-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110886481186605
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99034285726530
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-slots-of-caribbean-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-99009937549697
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-snake-bricks-bounce-balls-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110756409503816
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-merge-racers-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96083249458024
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-hack-need-for-drift-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-110916671933541
    https://peatix.com/user/8532135
    https://pagalguy.com/discussions/new-carrot-defense-hd-hack-mod-apk-cheats-generator-ios-android-96082816169540

Comments are closed.